Fixed price vs time and materials: how to choose for your project
Fixed price fits work you can scope, and time and materials fits work you can't. How we price builds, scoping, retainers and hours, with our published prices.
- Business
- Project Management
If you're buying a website or an internal tool for a B2B team, pick a fixed price when you can write the scope down before work starts. Pick time and materials for the part you can't scope yet, or for work that keeps going after launch.
At Concealed we sell both. When a project's goals can be scoped, we fix the price. Scoping and ongoing work have a weekly or monthly price agreed up front, Changes after launch are priced from our hourly rate, but estimated in bulk, per feature or group of features, before the work starts.
Grafibeira, a print shop, ran production on paper job sheets and spreadsheets updated by hand. We built its production management system in four weeks on a fixed scope, and its team now saves two hours a day. What its operators asked for once the system was running came after, as 90+ further hours of features.
Fixed price and time and materials, side by side
Under a fixed price, you and the studio agree what gets built and what it costs before anything starts. Under time and materials (T&M), you pay for the hours worked at an agreed rate, plus costs like software or hosting, for as long as the work runs.
| Fixed price | Time and materials | |
|---|---|---|
| What you agree first | The scope, the price and the timeline | An hourly or daily rate |
| When you know the total | Before work starts | When work ends |
| Who pays if it takes longer | The studio | You |
| What a change costs | A new scope and price for the change | More hours on the bill |
| What you manage | The result, at each milestone | The hours, every week |
The biggest difference is when the hard thinking happens. With a fixed price, it happens before the build. With T&M, it happens during the build, and you pay for it as it goes.
Can you write the scope down?
US federal buyers use the same test. Their acquisition rules allow a time-and-materials contract only when the extent or duration of the work can't be estimated accurately, or its costs anticipated with reasonable confidence, at the moment of signing (FAR 16.601, paragraph c).
The same test works for a small business. If you can list the pages, the screens, the people who use them and what they need to do, the work can be priced. If you can't yet, any fixed quote you get is a guess with a margin on top. T&M is the honest way to pay for the part nobody understands.
Plenty of projects sit between the two, with a clear goal and unclear details. For those, scope first and fix the price after.
Why we fix the price when the scope is clear
A Framer website is $2,000 for a single page and $8,000 for up to eight pages. Internal tools, apps and MVPs start at $10,000, scoped at a fixed price. Once the scope is written, the proposal fixes the price and the timeline, and they don't change halfway through.
Our reason is the incentive. Billing a whole build by the hour puts the client in the position of watching the clock. Every extra call or iteration costs something nobody planned.
With a fixed price, if we underestimate the work, that's on us and we absorb the cost. If we finish early, the client pays the same agreed price. Catarina Coimbra, our COO, wrote about how that changed the studio in how transparent pricing changed how we work.
It also changes what you watch during the project. On an app build, you see working builds at each milestone and judge the work itself.
What a fixed price costs you
A fixed price has trade-offs, and you should hear them before you sign.
The scope has to be written down first, and that takes your time as well as ours. Feedback is part of the price but has limits, with one round on a single-page site and two on a multi-page site.
When your process changes after launch, which is normal, we scope the change as it comes up. You can cancel a project anytime, and payments for work already under way aren't refunded.
Grafibeira shows how the two fit together. The fixed scope solved one problem: an overview of every job in production and of the work coming up. Once the floor used it every day, the team wanted more, such as tracking with scan readers, UX fixes the operators reported, a PDF export of an item's history, a production calendar and a kanban view. None of that was in the fixed price. It came after launch, estimated feature by feature from our hourly rate as the team found what it needed (the second phase tells it).
When paying for time is the right call
Three kinds of work don't fit a fixed price for the whole job, and we sell each one differently.
The first is scope nobody has pinned down. For a tool, app or MVP whose scope is unclear, the Scoping Sprint buys a short, fixed block of time at $2,500 a week, usually one to two weeks. It ends in a defined scope, a timeline and a fixed quote for the build. The fee is credited to the build if you go ahead, and if you don't, you've spent one or two weeks of budget and know what the project would take.
The second is work that never ends. A site that keeps growing or a product with a roadmap has no final scope to price. The request lane is $6,500 a month for one request in progress at a time, design or development, and you can pause or cancel monthly. A dedicated senior designer is $8,000 a month and a developer $10,000, working on your roadmap, with 30 days' notice to cancel.
The third is what an internal tool needs after launch. Once it's live, you choose between a retainer and ad-hoc hours. By default we estimate each feature or group of features in bulk from our hourly rate and agree that price before starting, so you know what you'll pay. When a client asks to work within a set budget of hours instead, we use ad-hoc hours, which are time and materials. Either way, it suits a backlog that changes as your team uses the tool.
The sprint and the retainers both have a price you know before the week or month starts. A retainer's bill stays the same whatever the month turned out to need.
How to choose for your project
Start from what you can write down today.
- You can list the pages, screens and users, and you need it by a date. Ask for a fixed price, and ask what the price includes, how many feedback rounds there are and how changes are handled.
- You know the goal but not the details. Pay for a short, time-boxed scoping phase, then fix the price for the build.
- The work keeps going, like a site that ships pages every month or a tool with a backlog. Buy capacity by the month at a price you know, or have occasional changes estimated a feature at a time.
If a studio offers only open-ended hourly billing for work that fits the first case, ask why. If it offers a fixed price for work that fits the second case without scoping it first, ask what the margin in the quote is for.
Frequently asked questions
Is time and materials cheaper than a fixed price?
It can be, when the work goes as planned, because a fixed quote carries the studio's allowance for the unexpected. With T&M you carry that risk yourself: the final bill stays lower only while the extra hours cost less than the allowance the fixed quote would have charged.
What is a capped time-and-materials contract?
It's T&M with an agreed maximum. You pay for the hours worked up to that ceiling, and once it's reached, you and the vendor decide together what still gets finished.
Can a project pay for time first and move to a fixed price?
Yes, and for an unclear tool or app it's often the best route. Our Scoping Sprint has a fixed weekly price and a fixed timeframe, and it ends in a fixed quote for the build.
How do I estimate my project before asking for quotes?
Write down the kinds of users, the main screens or workflows and the systems it must connect to. Our custom software cost calculator turns those answers into a price range and a timeline.
Fix the price once the scope is written
How much of your project you understand today decides how you should pay for it. Pay for time only on the part you can't describe yet, and fix the price on everything else.
If you can describe what you need and we're a fit, we'll scope it and give you a fixed price and timeline. If you can't yet, we'll tell you whether a Scoping Sprint makes sense. Book a call and bring whatever you have written down.
Written by João Saraiva, founder of Concealed, a Framer Expert studio in Lisbon building websites and custom internal tools.
